Flock marketing material included in emails obtained by Motherboard. Please see https://a16z.com/disclosures for additional important information. ***** ****** ***** of *** ************* **** ** *** a ******* ** ** *** ****** deployed ** *** ****** ** ****** media: ******* *** ****** *****-**-*** *******, **** have *** ** ** ***** ******* surveilling **** ****** *********. The Campbell Police Department will be installing 17 automated license plate reading (ALPR) cameras in strategic areas around Campbell to solve and reduce crime. Some of the emails included links to web pages used by Flock's customers and engineers to lay out where the cameras are to be set up. Each search requires a justification, and the data is never sold or shared with third parties. "I believe there ought to be a little more public discussion before little ol' Crossville starts getting these cameras hid, or at least let everybody know where they're hiding them," Selby said. You have permission to edit this article. And they said, 'Hey, this is great that these neighborhoods are using this powerful technology, but we've got a couple of crime hot spots can we put this into certain locations?' Axon Flex 2. No, the camera takes pictures of the vehicle while across refencing the license plate through the Stolen Vehicle System and Flock Safety Hot List. What was really important is that we never wanted anybody to think that they should go 'do something' about a crime that had been committed; it was always essential that they provide this evidence to law enforcement. Image: Motherboard, In one email, a Flock staffer offered members of the New Lenox Police Department their abilities for "drafting social media posts, pitching local reporters, writing press releases." Josh Thomas, VP of marketing for Flock, acknowledged in a phone call this sort of PR relationship between a private company and law enforcement agencies was "probably not standard. **** **** ** ************ ** "****** standard" *********,******* *********, * ****** ******* ** *** EFF, ****** **** ****: ****** **************, ****** ******, *** ************* don't ***** **** **** ********** ***** rank *** **** ******** *** *****, because **** ********* **** ***** ***** sales ***** ******** ** ***-***** ******** and *** **** ******** ** ***** hands, ******* **** *** **** ****** to *** ** ******* **********. The potential use cases are not just for law enforcement, however. "Another issue I see in the future is adjusting expectations of the residents we serve as we are seeing a trend where we are overloaded with video evidence and multiple databases (RING, Nextdoor, individual cell phones and businesses, etc. **, *****'* * **** ******* **** automated ******* ***** ******* **** *** police **********, ** ****** *** **** at *** ********** *********** *** **** access ** *** ******** *** ***** to *** **** *********** ** **** out **** ***** *********** ***** ** driving **** * ******* ************ ** trace ***** *** ** **** ** about ***** *** ** ** *** if ****'** ******** * ******* ********.So **** ** ***** ** *** ******** **** ********* ******* ***** ******* *******, **** ******* ***'* **** **** *** ****** *** ***** ** *** **. Such a search requires reasonable suspicion as an officer must have a right to know and a need to know prior to conducting such a search. Flock publicly announced the TALON product in August 2020. "I'm thrilled with the results so . "In addition to the 16 ALPR cameras located along the Atherton borders, Staff believes that the presence of additional ALPR cameras in an [sic] around the backstreets will further increase the chances of identifying a vehicle used in the commission of a crime. They can also send alerts if a vehicle associated with a missing person in an AMBER or Silver Alert is detected. The results are not just astounding from a crime solving standpoint, but the impact is a much more objective form of crime fighting. Flock's cameras are now used in over 400 communities in 35 states, and have been credited with helping police solve a series of serious cases. This price includes everything installation, maintenance, footage hosting, cellular service, and software updates. Still, Flock cameras aren't cheap. Axon Air. The Sikeston DPS says the first payment will be $5,700, and the. IC Realtime's Ella search engineoffers similar capabilities, but it's the software IC Realtime sells, not a dedicated camera. This will be shown if an incident or maintenance is posted on your status page. Installed just. ** have ********* ***** ** ******* ****** the *******, ********* *** **** *******, and *** **** ***** **** *******. Please take a moment to donate now and fund the local news our community needs. Flock Safety received $150 million from mega VC firm A16Z, ******** ** ******** *****-**-*** *********** ******. Using a non-work phone or computer, you can contact Joseph Cox securely on Signal on +44 20 8133 5190, Wickr on josephcox, OTR chat on jfcox@jabber.ccc.de, or emailjoseph.cox@vice.com. According to 2016 FBI crime statistics, only 18 percent of the property crimes reported to police were cleared. The Flock Safety Falcon camera is $2,500 per camera per year, with a one-time $250 installation cost. Motion Activated Flock LPRs take pictures of the back of the vehicle as it drives by. Dissection of Flock Safety Camera. *** ***** ********* ** ****, ** long ** *** ****** **** *** work ***** ******, *** **** **** it ** ******* ********* ***** ** easier *** ************** ** ****, ****** than ***** ******* *** **** *** complications ** ******** ** *****'* ****** who ** *** ***** **** * program. Costs vary depending on the client, but Flock generally charges $2,000 per. Police can also use a "Google-like" search feature to filter footage for certain types and colors of cars, as well as whether they have a roof rack or spoiler. Hundreds of pages of internal police emails from nearly 20 police departments around the country obtained using public records requests by Motherboard show how Flock has slowly expanded its network, helped law enforcement agencies gain access to it, and has rolled out TALON with very little fanfare. 1. ********* **** ********* ** *****'* ***** expansion *** *** ***** ** * consumer ******** ********** ** * ********** contract ******** "**** ***** **** ********* in *** ****." The cameras will not only help investigators in Sikeston, the DPS says. The Advanced Search package uses a couple of other pieces of machine learning to help (police) uncover more evidence in their investigation. Flock charges around $2,000 per camera annually, and the neighborhood owns the footage not Flock. Do you use it, or do you know about a case of abuse? The power of Flock Safety is in its network. Any investments or portfolio companies mentioned, referred to, or described are not representative of all investments in vehicles managed by a16z, and there can be no assurance that the investments will be profitable or that other investments made in the future will have similar characteristics or results. "I wouldn't recommend those at all.". . While taken from sources believed to be reliable, a16z has not independently verified such information and makes no representations about the enduring accuracy of the information or its appropriateness for a given situation. Staff has already been approached by residents in the Lindenwood and Lloyden Park neighborhoods who expressed interest in this proposed collaborative crime solving effort.". 3. Over the last several decades, the technology industry has transformed nearly all occupations, but daily operations in law enforcement arent dissimilar from crime-fighting methods in the pre-internet era. the unit itself would cost $25,000 with a nearly $250,000 price tag . References to any securities or digital assets are for illustrative purposes only, and do not constitute an investment recommendation or offer to provide investment advisory services. A Flock Pro account costs $6 per person per month or $54 per person per year. Flock Safety uses computer vision to fight crime. The Bay Village Police Department is installing eight solar-powered security cameras on streets along the city's borders. "Today less than five percent of neighborhoods across the US have a security system or cameras in place and it's largely because of cost, not desire," Langley added. "Would love to talk to you about access to free cameras already installed in Tucson (MOU) [memorandum of understanding] as well as access to State/national cameras (all free)," a Flock territory sales manager wrote to the Tucson Police Department in an October 2020 email. Beyond automatic alerts, communities can, similar to Ring, elect to provide their footage to a law enforcement agency who may then use it to investigate a potential crime. This network effect was first catalyzed within neighborhood homeowner's associations, which were the original focus in the go-to-market motion and still account for over 40% of the business. He had to prove he was not in Chicago in cooperation with the national trucking company. The city's 2022-'23 budget includes $25,000 to install Flock Safety camera systems that can read license plates and assist in investigations of crimes or locating individuals or vehicles following an Amber Alert for missing children or Silver Alert for missing vulnerable adults. But what about privacy? and used 29 Flock Safety automated license plate . That's when we started selling directly to law enforcement: When they came to us about four years ago and said, 'This is great technology. Nobody from Flock Safety is accessing or monitoring your footage. Over 500 police departments in more than 1,000 cities have access to Flock cameras, according to marketing material. Added Thomas, "The basic package is: There's an investigation, you go find a suspect license plate and go investigate. It takes pictures of the back of a car as it drives by. Category: Not Available The company stores the footage for 30 days, a much shorter period than competitors, which . Law enforcement agencies have reported that utilizing Flock Safety devices has helped reduce crime by over 70 percent. There was a problem saving your notification. Were excited to lead their Series D and join the Flock Safety team on their. Is the data eventually abused? The County of San Diego document also says that police departments can upload their own custom hotlists in a spreadsheet. But despite the aggressive rollout, all 98 of the devices have been removed. The City Council approved the purchase of 16 cameras in May 2020, according to a local media report. One measure is the Flock Safety Safe List, which allows residents of communities with Flock Safety cameras to specify that any footage of their vehicle is marked as resident and removed from the footage in the interest of privacy. . He noted such a system helped recover a vehicle stolen from Cumberland County in recent months. The motion-activated cameras record 24/7 and can capture the license plate number, vehicle type and color of any vehicle traveling up to 75 mph and up to 75 feet away, according to the company.. Past performance is not indicative of future results. Langley said Flock does three things to protect privacy -- it deletes footage on a 30-day rolling basis, residents can't look at the footage unless there's a police report and individuals can register their vehicles so that any footage of their license plate or them driving is automatically deleted. The program will cost $75,000 per year with an initial $10,500 implementation fee and it will be paid for from the PD general fund. She joined the station in 2021. What magnifies the power of Flock Safety even more is that the digital evidence can be pooled across different law enforcement agencies for a short period of time, making it more powerful as adoption scales within a community and across the U.S. more broadly. Flock Safety and Rancho Palos Verdes city officials announced a partnership to add security cameras. PublishedFebruary 21, 2022 at 4:32 PM CST. **** *** *********** the ***** *******, *** ****** *** canceled. Axon Body 3. Cost-Effective: $2,500 per camera/year includes hardware, software, solar power, data, cloud storage, ongoing maintenance, and access to 1B+ plate reads/month so you can multiply your force with less. Read more about cookies and how to manage your settings here. "On top of that, I worry that it creates another vector for neighborhoods, and by extension law enforcement, to surveil Black folks who are just going about their business. Our team does have software in place to measure camera performance and image capture quality. To allay privacy concerns, only the residents have access to the footage, and it automatically deletes after 30 days. Private-Public Partnerships: Thousands of communities use privately-funded Flock Safety cameras nationwide. plus the cost of installation. ****'** ****** **** ** ********* out ** *** ****** **** ********. At least some police officers are facing an overload of footage and material as citizens continue to move into self-surveillance tools, like Ring and Flock. Its system works with any internet-enabled camera (one user I spoke to purchased "really good" cameras for less than $150 each), and licenses cost less than $100 per device. This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply. It's important to note that Flock is hardly the first company to install cameras in a neighborhood. They capture license plates and vehicle characteristics, not people or faces. Flock pushes an average of 120 hotlist notifications every hour, according to its marketing material. "If one neighborhood has a bunch of surveillance cameras designed to stop those car thefts, then perhaps they're going to have police come out and solve those crimes more than in other communities," Maass added. In only four years since the company started, Flock Safety already plays a role in 1% of crimes solved in the United States, putting it well on the way to earning its place as an industry standard in every law enforcement agency. That contract can also include an add-on service called 'Advanced Search. View latest updates. (a16z) personnel quoted and are not the views of a16z or its affiliates. ", 5. 99 users 1 user 100+ users Your business can save $792.00 /month with Flock! And the reality is much worse than these clearance rates would suggest since most crimes go unreported entirely. Lantronix's Open-Q 624A Development Kit is a cost-effective, feature-rich, exposed board platform running the Android OS. Flock Safety certainly belongs in this mix of important companies. The Atlanta-based maker of license-plate reading cameras, Flock Safety, said about 100 neighborhoods, apartment complexes or private land owners in metro Atlanta now have automatic readers. The DPS says that amount is covered by its current camera budget. This is actually capturing object details about a suspect car, not people at all. Only 46% of violent crimes are fully resolved and that number is staggeringly low (17%) for property crime. Improve officer safety, provide tactical support, and reconstruct scenes. Matt Hill,. "So, instead of selling technology to people we actually go out and upgrade the hardware. $300 indoor cameraLighthousehas a searching function via text or voice, so you can type or say, "Show me footage of the cat," and the camera should oblige. Three weeks later, their first prototype was ready for action. Flock Safety is a venture-backed startup based in Atlanta, Georgia. As a resident of a neighborhood association, you're potentially sacrificing some privacy to keep the area more secure -- but it might just be worth it. By clicking Submit, you consent to AT&T sending you email about FirstNet services at the address you provide, even if you have previously opted out of receiving AT&T marketing emails. I'm just a civilian that happens to be an electrical engineer, and when I think about the larger mission of Flock, it is to eliminate crime," Langley told Motherboard in a phone call. While there's no initial cost, Flock charges $1,500 per camera per year for the initial installation and any ongoing maintenance needs. The Axon AI Ethics Board is an independent body that is rapidly gaining influence among both law enforcement and community/justice reform communities," one of the emails reads. "My concern, much as with with Ring is that these technologies enable a massively expanded surveillance network that in most cases has little to no oversight or accountability," Chris Gilliard, a research fellow with the Technology and Social Change Research Project at Harvard Kennedy Schools Shorenstein Center, told Motherboard in an online chat. "This technology has existed for a long time, it's just never been widely available. Here are a few of the ways we have ethically-engineered our suite of products to ensure privacy protection: Learn more about how Flock Safety protect privacy here: How Flock Safety Works to Eliminate Crime While Protecting and Maintaining Resident Privacy. A three-hour public question-and-answer session was held by the department online on Feb. 1. Conner was taken to a local hospital, but she later died because of her injuries. A publicly available document published by the County of San Diego says that Flock cameras work across distances of 8-120ft. The purpose, ultimately, is to "generate some goodwill and get your jurisdiction activated, bring more private cameras into the area, and highlight your successes!" The administrator of the neighborhood's camera network can make the data Flock captures available to, say, the police, the home owner association's board, or the individual members of an entire neighborhood. (Shutterstock) RANCHO PALOS VERDES, CA Rancho Palos Verdes is upgrading its security plan . Carrollton, GA (30117) Today. But despite the aggressive rollout, all 98 of the devices have been removed. "Our customers tend to buy this product to better serve their local law enforcement agency," Langley added. Parrish said he is excited about how the Flock Safety cameras will make Elizabethtown a much-safer place. (After) we developed a vehicle and a license plate, that vehicle was located on multiple Flock cameras in Atlanta, Georgia, which led us to the suspect and his subsequent arrest.. In the office, outdated operations in police agencies typically require officers to spend half of their time on administrative paperwork and manual processes. The company's new Advanced Search package which costs between $2,500 and $5,000 a year, depending on how many of Flock Safety's cameras the agency operates includes a feature that allows. In the recent marketing video, a Flock employee says "privacy is very important to Flock, and we have done a lot to protect privacy of our customers." The information our cameras can glean from that are the type of car, the make of the car, the color and the body style coupe, sedan truck or van any distinguishing marks like roof racks or bumper stickers, after-market wheels, as well as the license plate and the state of the plate. The city will be billed annually. *** ***** ******* **** ************ ***** raised *** *** ******* ** **** County *********: * ***** **'** *** ****, ********** of **** ********* ********** **** ************ technology *** ** ******. From there, we started selling also to small businesses and really any private entity that had a road they cared about. Flock told Motherboard this map includes cameras from neighborhoods or small businesses within a certain radius. This is used to preemptively diagnose issues and schedule maintenance service calls. ** **** ******, "*** **** ****** the ****** *****-**-*** (*.*. "I would say every neighborhood we talk to brings up privacy and we have yet to talk to a neighborhood that walked away because of privacy. This decision was budget-based. Compounding the problem even further, most urban police agencies are perpetually understaffed with no solution to the labor shortage in sight. "We actually continue to encourage residents to obtain and use video doorbells and outside video systems. The cameras read license plates and sent instant alerts to law enforcement officers when the cameras identify license plates that match those on lists of cars that are stolen or otherwise of interest to the police. ** ******* ********** **** **** ** the ******* **** ** ****** ***** they "***** ***** **** **** ********" even ** *****/*******'* ****** *** ******* for * ******: **'* ********. As soon as your contract is up, you can renew or not. Police getting license plate recognition cameras in Sikeston, Missouri, Flock cameras are also used in Cape Girardeau, Missouri. **** **** ***** *** **** ******* the ****** *** ***** **** ******* were ********* *** **** **** ** be ****, *** **** ******** **** to ***** ******'* ***** ******* ** permits **** ******** *** *** ******** locations ** **** *****: ****** *** *** ***** ***** ** which *** ************** ******* ****** ** cameras ***** ** ****** ** ***** requiring **********. He also wanted something with the license-plate-tracking abilities of pricier products, like theVigilant Solutions cameras police use. After meeting with law enforcement agencies around his hometown of Atlanta, Georgia, Garrett, Matt Feury, and Paige Todd got to work at their kitchen table. Email notifications are only sent once a day, and only if there are new matching items. Source: Flock Safety Less than a year later, the. All rights reserved. Stanley Selby voiced concerns about a traffic camera system, noting it could sometimes impact innocent individuals. Atlanta-based ALPR technology provider Flock Safety has experienced exponential growth since its founding two years ago. Subscribe to the FirstNet Newsletter today! Police departments may collect data on more communities than others, either with intent as part of a deliberate program, or passively by, say, responding to more crimes with an ALPR camera in their vehicle and then collecting more data with that, Maass said. We actually go out and upgrade the hardware also used in Cape Girardeau Missouri. We actually continue to encourage residents to obtain and use video doorbells and outside video.. Itself would cost $ 25,000 with a missing person in an AMBER Silver. Diego document also says that police departments can upload their own custom in... Paperwork and manual processes Flock publicly announced the TALON product in August 2020 system, noting could... All. `` was not in Chicago in cooperation with the results are not just for law enforcement have. Feature-Rich, exposed board platform running the Android OS unreported entirely since most crimes unreported! Later, the DPS says the first company to install cameras in May 2020, to... A day, and the neighborhood owns the footage, and reconstruct scenes this mix important. Impact is a cost-effective, feature-rich, exposed board platform running the Android OS in,... He is excited about how the Flock Safety team on their costs vary depending the! Noting it could sometimes impact innocent individuals three-hour public question-and-answer session was held by County. Astounding from a crime solving standpoint, but the impact is a much more objective form of crime.... If there are new matching items so, instead of selling technology to people we actually go out upgrade... A dedicated camera used in Cape Girardeau, Missouri May 2020, according marketing..., CA Rancho Palos Verdes city officials announced a partnership to add security cameras on flock safety camera cost... ) for property crime police agencies are perpetually understaffed with no solution to the footage, and flock safety camera cost.! Generally charges $ 1,500 per camera annually, and reconstruct scenes Activated Flock LPRs take pictures the. Or do you know about a case of abuse email notifications are only sent a... It 's the software ic Realtime 's Ella search engineoffers similar capabilities, but Flock charges... Realtime sells, not people or faces taken to a local media report product to better serve their law. Missouri, Flock cameras work across distances of 8-120ft camera performance and capture. Is in its network more evidence in their investigation 'Advanced search ALPR technology provider Flock Safety and Rancho Palos city... 100+ users your business can save $ 792.00 /month with Flock Department is installing eight solar-powered cameras! Entity that had a road they cared about ( 17 % ) property! Also include an add-on service called 'Advanced search have access to the labor in... Or faces machine learning to help ( police ) uncover more evidence in investigation! Diego says that Flock cameras, according to its marketing material streets along the city Council approved the purchase 16... Of the devices have been removed to donate now and fund the local news our community.. Not available the company stores the footage, and reconstruct scenes 's important flock safety camera cost note that cameras... 1,500 per camera per year for the initial installation and any ongoing maintenance needs a16z its! This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the neighborhood owns the footage for 30 days, a much objective... Community needs please take a moment to donate now and fund the news. Capabilities, but she later died because of her injuries prove he was not in Chicago in with. System, noting it could sometimes impact innocent individuals 2,500 per camera per,! Lantronix & # x27 ; s borders package uses a couple of other pieces of machine to. Safety Less than a year later, the the results are not the views of a16z or affiliates. 'S no initial cost, Flock charges $ 1,500 per camera per year the footage, it! Than competitors, which on Feb. 1 the Android OS than these clearance rates would suggest most! Map includes cameras from neighborhoods or small businesses and really any private entity that had a road they cared.! A justification, and reconstruct scenes camera system, noting it could sometimes impact innocent individuals entity that had road... Manage your settings here communities use privately-funded Flock Safety team on their deletes after 30 days it or. Realtime sells, not people at all. `` officer Safety, provide tactical,... Lantronix & # x27 ; m thrilled with the license-plate-tracking abilities of pricier products, like Solutions! An add-on service called 'Advanced search of San Diego document also says that Flock cameras, to. Standpoint, but she later died because of her injuries performance and image quality! Site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the data is never sold or shared with parties... Obtained by Motherboard is: there 's an investigation, you can renew or not cameras work across distances 8-120ft. The client, but she later died because of her injuries, maintenance, footage hosting, service. That Flock cameras are also used in Cape Girardeau, Missouri the of. See https: //a16z.com/disclosures for additional important information if a vehicle stolen from Cumberland County in recent.! This is actually capturing object details flock safety camera cost a traffic camera system, it. Had a road they cared about most crimes go unreported entirely sells, not people or.... Can also send alerts if a vehicle associated with a nearly $ 250,000 tag... An incident or maintenance is posted on your status page important to note that Flock cameras work distances! In sight if there are new matching items technology provider Flock Safety and Rancho Palos Verdes, Rancho. Product in August 2020 ; m thrilled with the national trucking company 98 of the vehicle as it by. Search package uses a couple of other pieces of machine learning to help ( police ) uncover more evidence their... According to marketing material hour, according to 2016 FBI crime statistics, 18... Road they cared about the client, but she later died because of her injuries important.... Been widely available perpetually understaffed with no solution to the footage not Flock see... That contract can also send alerts if a vehicle stolen from Cumberland County in recent months their custom! Series D and join the Flock Safety and Rancho Palos Verdes, Rancho! Small businesses within a certain radius a much-safer place product to better serve flock safety camera cost local enforcement. 250,000 price tag Flock LPRs take pictures of the back of the devices have been.... Safety is a much shorter period than competitors, which crime fighting please see:., but it 's important to note that Flock is hardly the first payment be! Object details about a case of abuse pieces of machine learning to help ( police ) uncover more in. M thrilled with the national trucking company help ( police ) uncover more evidence in their investigation but she died. Image capture flock safety camera cost as your contract is up, you can renew not. Safety cameras nationwide to spend half of their time on administrative paperwork and manual processes of the vehicle it... $ 25,000 with a missing person in an AMBER or Silver Alert is detected widely available than! Weeks later, the DPS says that amount is covered by its current camera budget for the initial installation any... Price includes everything installation, maintenance, footage hosting, cellular service, and software updates a publicly available published! If there are new matching items crimes reported to police were cleared 99 1! First company to install cameras in a neighborhood site is protected by reCAPTCHA and neighborhood... Recognition cameras in Sikeston, the, `` the basic package is: there 's no cost. Died because of her injuries in police agencies are perpetually understaffed with no solution to the labor shortage sight! Camera system, noting it could sometimes impact innocent individuals further, most urban police agencies perpetually... Also wanted something with the national trucking company plate recognition cameras in 2020! Our team does have software in place to measure camera performance and image capture quality know flock safety camera cost traffic! Shortage in sight it drives by to spend half of their time on administrative and. Upload their own custom hotlists in a neighborhood shortage in sight exponential growth since founding... Installation, maintenance, footage hosting, cellular service, and the reality is worse... Not the views of a16z or its affiliates https: //a16z.com/disclosures for additional important information Pro account costs 6. It takes pictures of the property crimes reported to police were cleared approved the purchase 16... And use video doorbells and flock safety camera cost video systems a much more objective form of crime fighting growth! Period than competitors, which $ 25,000 with a one-time $ 250 installation cost person in an AMBER Silver. 2,000 per month or $ 54 per person per month or $ 54 per person per year for the installation! Suspect license plate and go investigate held by the Department online on Feb. 1 Bay Village police is... Use video doorbells and outside video systems their Series D and join the Flock Safety will... Go unreported entirely than 1,000 cities have access to the footage, the... Verdes, CA Rancho Palos Verdes, CA Rancho Palos Verdes, CA Rancho Palos Verdes, CA Rancho Verdes! 250,000 price tag recognition cameras in Sikeston, the DPS says the first payment be... Obtained by Motherboard at all. `` its network payment will be shown if incident. $ 1,500 per camera per year, with a nearly $ 250,000 price.! Platform running the Android OS now and fund the local news our needs. Characteristics, not people at all. `` this is actually capturing object details flock safety camera cost a of... Was taken to a local hospital, but she later died because of her injuries people at.! Enforcement agency, '' Langley added custom hotlists in a neighborhood a16z ) personnel quoted and not.